Towing a car is always a stressful situation, even if it is legal. But when, after returning the car, you discover Bent, scratched or broken rims, stress turns to rage. Who's to blame? How to prove damage? And most importantly, how can I get my money back for repairs or new discs? This article will help you understand the legal nuances, technical aspects of assessing damages, and practical steps to protect your rights.

Many drivers mistakenly believe that a tow truck is a “sacred cow” and that nothing can be recovered from it. In fact Federal Law No. 257-FZ "On Highways" and Civil Code of the Russian Federation clearly regulate liability for damage during transportation. The main thing is to correctly record the facts and not miss deadlines. Next, we will go through step by step what to do if your discs were damaged by the careless actions of a tow truck or impound lot employees.

📊 How often have you experienced car towing?
Never
1-2 times throughout your life
Regularly (once a year or more often)
My car was towed right now

1. First steps: how to detect disk damage

Once you have gained access to the vehicle after evacuation, don't drive and drive away — first inspect the car. Discs are a part that can easily be damaged if improperly loaded or transported. Here's what to do immediately:

First, take a photo or video of all the wheels from different angles. Pay special attention to:

  • 🔍 Scratches and chips on the front and inside of the disc
  • 🌀 Rim deformation (curvature, "figure of eight") - check by rotating the wheel
  • 🛠️ Traces of contact with a tow truck (for example, metal scuffs from cables)
  • 🚗 Tire condition - sometimes damage to the disc leads to a puncture or swelling of the rubber

Secondly, find witnesses. These could be:

  • 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Other drivers in the impound lot
  • 📸 Parking lot employees (their testimony can then be officially requested)
  • 🚔 Traffic police inspectors, if they were present during the evacuation

The third step is to ask the employees of the impound lot or evacuation service Car acceptance certificate. It should contain a note about external damage. If she is not there - don't sign the document and demand changes. Without this act, it will be extremely difficult to prove the tow truck’s guilt.

💡

If the impound lot refuses to draw up a report with notes about the damage, write a complaint addressed to the head of the traffic police demanding that the car be inspected in your presence.

2. Who is to blame: the tow truck, the impound lot or you yourself?

According to the law, responsibility for the safety of the car during evacuation and storage lies with organization that carried out the transportation. It could be:

  • 🚛 Private towing company (under agreement with the traffic police)
  • 🏢 Municipal service (if the evacuation was carried out by law enforcement agencies)
  • 🅿️ Penalty parking (if damage occurred already in the storage area)

However, there are nuances. For example, if the disks were already damaged before evacuation, and you didn’t notice this, it will be impossible to prove the tow truck’s fault. That's why it's so important to have photo or video of the car BEFORE evacuation (for example, from a registrar).

Another controversial point - quality of road surface. If a tow truck was driving a car through potholes and the rims were bent from impacts, the fault lies with the carrier. But if the damage occurs due to faulty suspension your car (for example, broken shock absorbers), this is already your responsibility.

To figure out who is to blame, ask yourself these questions:

  • 🔹 Were the discs intact? up to evacuation? (is there evidence?)
  • 🔹 Are traces visible on the discs? contact with a tow truck (cables, hooks, metal snags)?
  • 🔹 Was the acceptance certificate drawn up with notes about damage?
What to do if the tow truck refuses to provide information about the carrier?

If the evacuation service refuses to name its organization or provide details, submit a request to the traffic police at the place of evacuation. They are required to provide information about the contractor within 30 days (based on Federal Law No. 59 “On the procedure for considering citizens’ appeals”).

3. Damage assessment: how much do bent wheels cost?

Before you claim compensation, you need to understand what kind of damage has been caused and how much it will cost. There are three types of disk damage:

Type of damage Signs Cost of repair/replacement (average for the Russian Federation)
Scratches/chips Visible burrs on the front or inside, do not affect the balance From 1,500 to 5,000 ₽ per disc (polishing, painting)
Rim deformation (figure eight) The wheel shakes when rotating, vibration at speeds >60 km/h From 3,000 to 10,000 ₽ per disc (editing on a machine)
Cracks/destruction Visible cracks, air leaking from the tire, the rim does not hold its shape Disk replacement: from 8,000 to 50,000 ₽ (depending on the model)
Damage to bolts/holes The thread is broken, the disc is not fixed to the hub From 2,000 to 15,000 ₽ (depending on the complexity of the restoration)

To accurately assess the damage you will need:

  1. Diagnostics at a service station - the technician must confirm that the damage could not occur during normal use.
  2. Independent expert's opinion — if you are planning a trial, the examination must be carried out according to the rules Federal Law No. 73 "On state forensic activity".
  3. Receipt for repairs or purchase of new disks — without it, collecting money will be difficult.

Important: if you repaired the disks yourself before assessing the damage, the court may refuse compensation, citing a lack of evidence. Therefore, fix the damage first, and then repair it.

Vehicle Passport (PTS)

Evacuation documents (protocol, acceptance certificate)

Photo/video of damage

Witness testimony (if any)

Receipt for advance payment of the examination (if required) -->

4. Pre-trial settlement: how to write a claim

Before going to court, try to resolve the issue peacefully. To do this you need to send claim to the guilty organization. In your complaint, be sure to include:

  • 📄 Details of the parties (your full name, address, contacts; name of the evacuation service/penalty station, their legal address)
  • 📅 Date and circumstances of evacuation (time, place, reason - refer to the traffic police protocol)
  • 🔧 Description of damage (with reference to the inspection report or examination)
  • 💰 Amount of damage (with receipts or estimates for repairs attached)
  • ⏳ Deadline for response (usually 10–30 days)

Sample claim:

To the Director of Evakuator-Service LLC

Ivanov I.I.


from Petrov Petr Petrovich,


registered at the address: Moscow, st. Lenina, 1, apt. 123



CLAIM


on compensation for damage caused to the car during evacuation



06/01/2026 my car (VIN: XTA12345678901234, state number A123BV 77)


was evacuated from the street. Gorky, 5 according to traffic police protocol No. 123456.


When returning a car from the impound lot (Address: Moscow, Transportnaya str., 10)


I discovered damage to the wheel rims: a bent rim on the front right wheel


and deep scratches on the rear left disc (photos attached).



According to expert opinion No. 789 dated 06/02/2026 (copy attached), the cost of repairs is 18,000 rubles.


I ask you to compensate for the damage caused within 10 days from the date of receipt of the claim.


to current account No. 12345678901234567890 at Sberbank PJSC.



If there is no response, I will be forced to go to court to recover damages,


as well as moral damages and legal costs.



Applications:


1. Copy of the evacuation protocol


2. Photos of damage (5 pcs.)


3. Expert opinion


4. Estimate for repairs



Date: 06/03/2026


Signature: __________ /Petrov P.P./

The claim can be sent to:

  • 📬 By registered mail with notification (via Russian Post)
  • 📧 By email (if the organization has an official e-mail)
  • 🏢 In person to the office (with a delivery note on your copy)
💡

If the guilty party ignores the claim or refuses to pay, collect all the evidence (copies of letters, receipts) - they will be needed in court.

5. Judicial practice: how to win a case regarding damaged disks

If pre-trial settlement does not work, the only option left is trial. According to statistics Moscow City Court, in 78% of cases, claims for compensation for damage from towing are satisfied in favor of drivers. But to win you need to prepare properly.

What documents will be needed:

  • 📄 Copy of the evacuation protocol
  • 📸 Photo/video of damage (with date and time of shooting)
  • 🔧 Conclusion of an independent examination
  • 💰 Receipts for repairs or purchase of new disks
  • 📜 A copy of the claim and proof of its sending (receipt receipt)
  • 👨‍⚖️ Testimony of witnesses (if any)

Typical mistakes made by plaintiffs that cause them to lose cases:

  • ❌ There is no certificate of acceptance and transfer of the car from the impound lot
  • ❌ The examination has been carried out after disk repair
  • ❌ The exact amount of damage is not indicated in the statement of claim
  • ❌ The plaintiff did not appear at the court hearing without good reason

Average amount of claims for such cases in 2026:

  • 🚗 For scratches/chips: 5,000–15,000 ₽
  • 🌀 For the “eight” disc: 15,000–30,000 ₽
  • 💥 For a complete disc replacement: 30,000–100,000 ₽ (depending on the car brand)

The period for consideration of a case in court is from 1 to 3 months. If the decision is in your favor, the guilty party must pay:

  • 💰 Cost of repair/replacement of disks
  • 📑 Legal costs (state fees, lawyer services)
  • 😡 Moral damage (if you require) - usually 5,000–20,000 ₽
💡

If the amount of the claim is less than 50,000 rubles, the case will be heard by a magistrate. It's faster and easier than district court.

6. Alternative ways to receive compensation

Court is not the only way to get your money back. Let's consider other options:

1. Insurance (CASCO or OSAGO)

  • If you have CASCO, damage to disks during evacuation is usually covered under the risk of “Damage from third parties”. But check the contract - some insurers exclude liability for the actions of government agencies.
  • OSAGO will not help here, since the tow truck is not a participant in the accident.

2. Complaint to the traffic police or prosecutor's office

  • If the evacuation was illegal (for example, without a protocol or in violation of the procedure), you can appeal the actions of the inspectors. In this case, the chances of compensation are higher.
  • The prosecutor's office may conduct an investigation into the negligence of evacuation service employees.

3. Contact Rospotrebnadzor

  • If the tow truck is a private company, you can write a complaint about violation of consumer rights (poor quality service provided).

4. Public pressure

  • Sometimes publishing in local media or social networks helps. Evacuation services do not like scandals and may make concessions.
What to do if the tow truck goes bankrupt?

If the towing company is liquidated or is in the process of bankruptcy, it will be difficult to recover money. In this case, you can try to file a claim against to the customer of services (usually the traffic police or the municipality), but the chances of success are low. An alternative is CASCO insurance (if available).

7. How to avoid problems in the future: prevention

To avoid dealing with damaged disks after evacuation, follow these simple rules:

Before evacuation:

  • 📸 Take regular photographs of the car (especially the wheels) - this will help prove their original condition.
  • 🔧 Check tire pressure and wheel balancing - malfunctions can aggravate damage during transportation.
  • 📄 Keep documents on disks (receipts, warranty) - this will simplify the assessment of damage.

During evacuation:

  • 🚨 Demand to be present when loading the car (this is your right according to Administrative regulations of the Ministry of Internal Affairs).
  • 📝 Record everything on video, especially the moment of attaching the cables to the wheels.
  • 🗣️ Verbally warn the tow truck about the price of the disks - sometimes this disciplines workers.

After evacuation:

  • 🔍 Do not sign the acceptance certificate without inspecting the car.
  • 📋 Request copies of all documents (protocol, act, receipt for payment of impound parking).

Important: If your car is towed regularly (for example due to lack of parking), consider installing protective rings for wheels or buying cheap steel wheels for the winter.

💡

The most reliable way to protect yourself is to document the condition of the car before and after evacuation. Without evidence, even the obvious guilt of the tow truck will remain unproven.

FAQ: Frequently asked questions about damaged disks during evacuation

❓ Is it possible to demand compensation if the discs were no longer new?

Yes, but the amount of compensation will be calculated based on market value of disks taking into account wear. For example, if a disk cost 20,000 rubles but lasted 3 years, an expert can reduce the amount of damage by 30–50%. However, even for old disks you can recover money - the main thing is to prove that they were in working order before the evacuation.

❓ What to do if the tow truck refuses to provide insurance information?

Any evacuation company is required to have a compulsory civil liability insurance agreement (analogous to MTPL for carriers). If they refuse to provide the policy, write a request to Rosstrakhnadzor with a request to check whether the organization has insurance. You can also file a complaint with antimonopoly service (FAS) for refusal to provide information.

❓ How much time do you have to file a claim?

The limitation period for such cases is 3 years from the moment you learned about the damage (Article 196 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). However, it is better not to delay: over time, evidence (photos, witness statements) may lose force. It is optimal to file a claim within 1-6 months after the incident.

❓ Is it possible to recover damages if the car was towed for debt?

Yes, even if the towing is related to debt collection (for example, a loan or fines), the carrier is responsible for the safety of the car. The main thing is to prove that the damage occurred during transportation or storage, and not before. In this case, the claim is filed not against the bailiffs, but against the towing company or impound lot.

❓ What to do if the discs were damaged in the impound lot, and not during evacuation?

In this case it's the fault impound lot, not a tow truck. The algorithm of actions is the same: record the damage, request a certificate, conduct an examination. The claim is being filed against the organization that manages the parking lot. Often these are municipal enterprises, so the process can take a long time - be prepared for a long correspondence with the administration.

⚠️ Attention: if you find disk damage a few days later After evacuation, it will be extremely difficult to prove a cause-and-effect relationship. The court may decide that the rims were bent while driving through potholes or as a result of an accident. Therefore, inspect the car immediately after returning from the parking lot.